ElBaradei: Is the Arab world ready for reform?

ElBaradei: Is the Arab world ready for reform?

Dr. Mohamed EdBaradei served as Director General of the UN’s International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) from December 1997 to November 2009. In 2005 he won the Nobel Peace Prize for his work. In 2009 he returned to Egypt where he is working for democratic reform. His name was circulated as a possible candidate to succeed President Hosni Mubarak in 2011.

In an interview with Mary Wald, Chairman of thecommunity.com, Dr. ElBaradei says that Egypt, once the locomotive for change in the Middle East, is going backwards.

This interview was conducted in 2010. We have left it up because of the ongoing interest in Dr. El Baradei’s comments, and because what he describes at the time — before the Arab Spring — proved itself in events, and continues to be relevant.

To stay abreast please join thecommunity.com.

TCC: You seem to be the first voice we have heard addressing the need for reform in Egypt in a very long time. You are starting by asking for a more democratic and open election process.

Is the Arab world ready for democratic reform this quickly? Or is it your sense that this will be a decades long process for Egypt?

MEB: I don’t think that any country is not ready. People are ready to enjoy the basic freedoms, freedom of speech, freedom of religion, freedom from want, freedom from fear and so on. People know that without democracy they are at a dead end.

You see this in Africa, in Ghana, in Botswana, excellent examples of democracy. People are ready.

The problem is how to get regimes to see it, to see that without democracy their country is stunted. In Egypt 40% of the population lives on less than $1 a day. 30% are illiterate. We are joining the list of Failed States. The country is deteriorating.

When people are repressed by their own governments, it leads to extremism.

It is not a question of whether change will come or not. No regime can ignore what is a clear message on the ground right now in the Arab world, that change is inevitable. Whether it comes in one year or five years, that train has already left the station. It will happen.

I think in the Arab world 90% of the people are supportive of change on both political and economic grounds, particularly the poor and the disenfranchised. The question is how to transfer that search for change into action.

There is sometimes a culture of fear that holds us back. I keep telling people that we need to send a clear message to the current regimes that it is time for a change, that we need to break the culture of fear, that our strength is in our numbers if we work collectively.

If we work collectively it will happen more quickly.

TCC: It seems to me that you could have quite a comfortable life in Vienna, with a few very nice honors, including the Nobel Peace Prize, to rest on.

What has made you jump into this?

MEB: Yes, my family keeps asking me the same question.

When I completed my term at the agency some people asked me to lend a hand.

I had been watching over the last years how Egypt had been deteriorating. Egypt has in the past been a model for modernization, and moderation. We have been losing that. We are losing our role as a beacon of culture for the Arab world. In many areas our country has actually been going backward.

If I had to look at this and say I could have effected change and didn’t do it, I would not have a clear conscience.

Looking at the region today makes you feel heartache. The Arab world is suffering. Someone needs to throw that first stone in the water and start the ripple.

To me, having a Nobel Peace Prize, it’s not just a medal. It’s a responsibility.

I want to say in the end that I gave it my all and lived up to that responsibility.

TCC: If you are successful, if you find yourself the next President of Egypt, what areas will you be looking at next for reform? And why? 

MEB: I would say education as the first area. Then health, and basic needs, such as jobs. But primarily education.

Because we can transform Egypt into a modern state, and a moderate state, through education. With education you have access to the rest of the world. You have technology. You have development. You get exposed to the universal values we all have to live with, including tolerance, social solidarity and respect for diversity, It builds harmony.

Education gives you perception and understanding. Everything we look for in terms of a good life comes with education.

TCC: If Egypt were to open itself up for the kind of changes you are asking for, what effect could it have on the region?

MEB: It could have tremendous impact. Egypt was always looked at by the rest of our region as a locomotive for progress. it was in the past a trail blazer. And there are 80 million people here.

That’s why there is a lot of support for reform in Egypt through the Arab world. It also makes some of the Arab regimes shiver a bit, as they see it coming as well in their own countries. And it will affect their countries.

TCC: Please clarify something for us in the West — the alliance with the Muslim Brotherhood. Our understanding of the Muslim Brotherhood is that they are seeking a Sunni Islamic empire running on Sharia law. How is this consistent with an agenda of democratization and reform?

MEB: It is true that the Muslim Brotherhood has a conservative view of religion. They also enjoy sizable degree of support in Egypt. They are currently the only effective opposition, with 20% of the Parliament. They provide many social services to the communities.

They have not used violence to achieve their ends for 40 or 50 years. They made it clear to me that they are not seeking a religious state but a civil state based on Islamic values (as it is currently the case under the Egyptian constitution) I made it clear however to them that a fundamental pre condition is the guarantee of equal rights to all Egyptians irrespective of their religion, ethnic origin etc.

I think that sometimes groups like these are painted in a way that is not a completely true picture. They are not the devil incarnate. I think sometimes the governments in the region try to paint these groups as more extremist than they are, to win the support of the West — by saying You see? If you don’t support us, the alternative will be much worse.

It’s also true that the liberal parties have not been given much of a chance in Egypt, so in a sense the Muslim Brotherhood has been the only game in town. But if you want to effect change in a country like ours, you cannot simply ignore a group that has that kind of support. They must be brought into the process. Reform has to be inclusive and we have to have the brotherhood as part of the coalition but subject to a constitution that guarantees the protection of universal values and basic freedoms for each and every one.

2 Comments

  1. Dear Dr. El-Baradei,

    I will not mention what I agree with you about, simply because I agree with ALL of what you’ve been promoting for the past few months. Given those embarrassing economic and human development indicators, I believe that no one, with just two healthy brain cells, could ever dare to argue that Egypt does not need radical change NOW. I have few comments/suggestions to share and one question:

    1) I really commend your tenacity in keeping your messages consistent with your idealistic framework. This is something rare in Egypt’s political arena, which I believe that you should continue on that path regardless of any opposition within your team.

    2) I am really impressed by your intelligence in not falling into the trap of revealing a political program (similar to those of the other political parties). I have reviewed and benchmarked the political programs of the top 5 political parties in Egypt… and guess what… They are essentially the same!! None of them is bold enough to stimulate Egyptian to share ONE common vision. In addition, they are full of ideals and seriously lack strategic pragmatism.

    3) Politics is about “presentation” more than “substance”. You have got good substance but I think that you lack the presentation part. I believe that you need some serious help in that aspect! Please forgive me for being blunt. Leaders are made nowadays by the media not by anything else.

    4) So far, you seem to me as a one-man (a great one) with a “choir team” rather than a “core-team”. I believe that you need a solid “Core Team”. Not only should that team share your beliefs, but should also share your strategic and tactical framework. I would suggest that such a team should be:

    a. A team that understands deeply the underlying complexities of “Change”.
    b. A team that is quite resourceful and devious when there is a need to be.
    c. A team that is unstoppable and solid enough to withstand “solar storms”.
    d. A team that DOES NOT consist of public figures. This is an important one.
    e. A team that is superb in innovating robust solutions during crises rather than making excuses and complaining.
    f.
    MY QUESTION:

    The situation in Egypt could be described in a nut-shell as: “a severely entangled hair-ball”. Are you confident of your ability to “untangle” such a hair-ball without getting “tangled” in it? If Yes, How would you do that?

    Thanks for your patience and good luck.

    Khaled Abou-Shady

  2. Dear Dr. El-Baradei,

    I will not mention what I agree with you about, simply because I agree with ALL of what you’ve been promoting for the past few months. Given those embarrassing economic and human development indicators, I believe that no one, with just two healthy brain cells, could ever dare to argue that Egypt does not need radical change NOW. I have few comments/suggestions to share and one question:

    1) I really commend your tenacity in keeping your messages consistent with your idealistic framework. This is something rare in Egypt’s political arena, which I believe that you should continue on that path regardless of any opposition within your team.

    2) I am really impressed by your intelligence in not falling into the trap of revealing a political program (similar to those of the other political parties). I have reviewed and benchmarked the political programs of the top 5 political parties in Egypt… and guess what… They are essentially the same!! None of them is bold enough to stimulate Egyptian to share ONE common vision. In addition, they are full of ideals and seriously lack strategic pragmatism.

    3) Politics is about “presentation” more than “substance”. You have got good substance but I think that you lack the presentation part. I believe that you need some serious help in that aspect! Please forgive me for being blunt. Leaders are made nowadays by the media not by anything else.

    4) So far, you seem to me as a one-man (a great one) with a “choir team” rather than a “core-team”. I believe that you need a solid “Core Team”. Not only should that team share your beliefs, but should also share your strategic and tactical framework. I would suggest that such a team should be:

    a. A team that understands deeply the underlying complexities of “Change”.
    b. A team that is quite resourceful and devious when there is a need to be.
    c. A team that is unstoppable and solid enough to withstand “solar storms”.
    d. A team that DOES NOT consist of public figures. This is an important one.
    e. A team that is superb in innovating robust solutions during crises rather than making excuses and complaining.
    f.
    MY QUESTION:

    The situation in Egypt could be described in a nut-shell as: “a severely entangled hair-ball”. Are you confident of your ability to “untangle” such a hair-ball without getting “tangled” in it? If Yes, How would you do that?

    Thanks for your patience and good luck.

    Khaled Abou-Shady

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Mohamed ElBaradei interview | Mary Wald - [...] read the interview Mohamed ElBaradei, nobel laureates, peace building [...]